Mosquitoes are awful. Growing up in Georgia I never had to worry about them, I never wore bug spray, and could go outside at any time, day or night, and not be bothered at all. But that’s not the story here. Here when I go outside for any prolonged amount of time after about 5pm it’s a feeding frenzy! And the crazy thing is that not just mosquitoes bite me! It’s mosquitoes, no-see-ums, gnats, and their whole extended family; it seems like everything that flies wants a piece of me!
Now, I think you and I are just like mosquitoes. How so? As they swarm around us, you and I swarm around lies, deceit, and dishonesty. Why? There’s something about lies, deceit, dishonesty, and gossip that sinners just can’t resist. We have to know the dirt on other people, we have to know the latest gossip, and then go tell others about it. Rather than being people who are concerned about truth we seem to be people who soak up falsehood like a sponge. John Calvin said it best, “Too many of us delight in a certain poisoned sweetness.”
Before we hear dig into the ninth commandment, remember how the Law begins, “I am the LORD your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery.” Church, God did not say ‘keep these commandments and I’ll rescue you.’ He said, ‘I have rescued you, so now live as I command.’ Every commandment, including this one, is spoken to a people who have already been rescued. Keep that in mind, as we enter the ninth commandment, because it does have much rebuke for us. But praise God it also gives us much help and direction.
As has been the case for a few weeks now, there are two headings to work through today: the negative command, and the positive command.
See first…
The Negative Command
Exodus 20:16 says, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.” The first image that comes to my mind when I read this verse is a courtroom. All those that bear witness in such a setting are under a sacred obligation to be truthful in all that’s said. That’s clear. But it’s also clear, that this command does not end when we leave the courtroom, but goes with us into all of life.[1]
What is it to bear false witness, what is it to lie? Generally, we could say to lie is to make an untrue statement. To lie is to speak differently from what you think, and to speak differently from what the thing itself is.[2] That’s good, but lying is more than that isn’t it? Of course it is. To lie is to make an untrue statement in order to mislead or deceive. So not only is lying a false word about something, but a false word in order to misrepresent and twist that something, for our own deceptive purposes.
History is as full of liars as the ocean is full of water. In the beginning, the serpent spoke opposite of what he knew to be true.[3] His first words uttered in the Bible, are in fact the first words about God from someone other than God, and they are lies. Lies made in order to cast doubt on God’s Word. “Did God really say, ‘You shall not eat of any tree in the garden? … For God knows that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.’” The serpent’s words simply weren’t true. God wasn’t worried about competitors, not at all.[4] He gave that command for man’s good. Yet the Devil cast doubt in Adam and Eve by lying to them, and they took the bait. Which in turn caused them to not be truthful about one another with God when He came asking questions.
These first lies began a long chain of deception. Cain continued the family legacy by lying to God about his part in Abel’s death. Abraham lied to Pharaoh about Sarah being his wife. Isaac followed suit and lied to Abimelech about Rebekah being his wife. Jacob lied to Isaac and stole the blessing by pretending to be Esau. The sons of Jacob deceived Shechem and Hamor in order to kill them and all their men after the defiling of their sister Dinah. Tamar deceived Judah in order to obtain children. Joseph’s brothers lied to Jacob about what really happened to Joseph. Those are only some of the lies in the rest of the book of Genesis. Many more follow throughout the rest of Scripture.
Bearing false witness might just be humanity’s favorite pastime. So naturally we find God writing it into Law in His commandments here in Exodus 20:16.
Leviticus 19:16 affirms this, “You shall not go around as a slanderer among your people, and you shall not stand up against the life of your neighbor: I am the LORD.” According to that, why are we not to do lie? The answer given is multifaceted. First, to lie is to slander neighbor. Second, to slander neighbor is to stand up against the life of neighbor. Third, we’re not to do this, because God says, “I am the Lord.” You may not think that is an answer, but it is. We’re not to lie, why? Because God is the God of Truth, meaning He is truthful, and is Himself the standard of all that is true. Numbers 23:19 agrees saying, “God is not man, that He should lie, or a son of man, that He should change His mind. Has He said, and will He not do it? Or has He spoken, and will He not fulfill it?” So Church, to lie is to go directly against God’s nature, to stand up against the life of your neighbor, to join yourself with falsehood, and to link arms with the Devil.
That sounds strong, I know. But listen to Jesus in John 8:44. There He’s speaking to those who are plotting to kill Him, and He says, “You are of your father the devil…When he lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies.” Jesus is not saying every person who ever lies becomes a child of the devil. He’s showing us where lying comes from, and who it resembles.
Truth-telling is godly because God is truth. Lying is satanic because Satan is the father of lies.
Paul often takes up this theme and calls us to put off lies and put on the truth. For example, in Colossians 3:9-10 he says, “Do not lie to one another, seeing that you have put off the old self with its practices and have put on the new self, which is being renewed in knowledge after the image of its creator.” We were rescued out of the Devil’s family, so when a Christian lies, it’s as if they’re willingly going back into the old house and picking up the old family habits. This grieves our Father, because it is not who we are anymore.
I don’t think any of this surprises us. Yet we lie. Let’s give examples of the many ways we lie. Here’s a few:
-We lie to others because sometimes…we don’t like the truth, so we don’t want to tell the truth.
-We lie about ourselves. About what we’ve done and not done, about what we’re doing and not doing, and about what we’ll do or won’t do.
-We lie about others. Rather than being truthful about others in conversation we naturally find ourselves talking about others in such a manner to bring them down and lift ourselves up. Maybe we don’t tell the whole truth about another person, but only speak of the bad they’ve done. Maybe we hold onto secrets we learn about others to use them later in a time that suits us.
-We lie by twisting words. Someone asks us, “What did they say?” and we give our own version of what they said rather than what they actually said. Or we re-tell events to make ourselves out to be the good guys and others the bad guys.
-We lie by gossip or slander. This occurs when we pass along information about another that they probably wouldn’t like us to share. We do this also when we hear another gossiping without stopping it. Silence is seen as acceptance and approval in this regard. I think this is where some prayer requests go bad. In a real effort to pray for someone we can easily spend more time “sharing” about their struggle than actually praying for them. And sometimes when we pray for them we don’t really pray for them, but give those around us a long list of the sins this person has committed.
-We also lie by beginning a statement with the phrase, “He’s a great guy, but…” or “She’s fantastic, but…” But what? Do you really think this guy or lady is great and fantastic if you have to add qualifiers onto the ends of our sentences and putting their shortcomings on display? This also brings those ridiculous sentimental statements into view when people say, “God bless him” or “Bless her heart” meaning anything but positive things. Our Mother’s advice rings true here. If you don’t have anything nice to say, don’t say anything at all. Don’t say it out loud, or in your heart. By remaining silent, we not only protect ourselves from becoming a liar and slanderer, we also protect the reputation of another by not airing out their dirty laundry before others.[5]
This is precisely what the ninth commandment has in view. It doesn’t merely say, “You shall not bear false witness.” It says, “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.” You see, so much here is about neighbor. God intends for us to not harm our neighbor’s name or reputation in how we speak to them or about them. We’re to uphold, protect, and do what we can to ensure our neighbor keeps their good name.
Do you do this? If you speak down of another (even if you think your reasons are righteously justifiable), or allow another to be spoken ill of in your presence without correcting them we break the ninth commandment, we reject God who is Truth and truthful, and we join ourselves to Satan the father or lies.
But pastor, ‘What about Rahab and the Hebrew midwives? Didn’t they lie and receive great blessing from God?’ Good question. Scripture commends their fear of God, their mercy to God’s people, and their faith (Heb 11:31). Scholars differ on how to read those accounts. But let me just say this. We shouldn’t build a whole theology of exceptions out of the hardest cases and then use it to excuse our own lying. 99,9% of our lies aren’t about hiding refugees. They’re about protecting ourselves.
Bottom line? Our words carry great weight. They can build up, and they can destroy. Lying is no small offense.
The Positive Command
I said it last week and I’ll say it again. Every commandment is two sided. Every commandment has a ‘thou shall not’ and a ‘thou shall.’ The Heidelberg Catechism we recited earlier states this clearly. We’re to love the truth, speak and confess it honestly, and do what we can to defend and promote our neighbor’s good name. So…if lying is the vice to avoid, the virtue to pursue is truth. Not just truth in general, but truth for your neighbor’s good. What does that look like? It looks like four things:
We must pursue the truth. “What is truth?” was Pilate’s question in John 18. But one chapter earlier, in John 17:17, Jesus had already answered it, “Sanctify them in the truth; Your Word is truth.” And in John 14:6 He says, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life.” So what is truth? Jesus is the Truth, and His Word is Truth. Church, you cannot speak truth to your neighbor if you’re not being shaped by the Truth yourself. That’s one reason why we read, study, meditate, and linger on God’s Word. It’s how truth gets into you.
We must acknowledge the truth. To acknowledge truth is to say it and stand for it, before God and before neighbor. That means being honest about ourselves and being honest with our neighbor. Honesty with ourselves means we own up to much, that we’re not always truth-tellers, but sometimes fall short of it, and need to ask for forgiveness. Honesty with neighbor means admitting this as well, and when needed, graciously telling them the truth too, whether it is directly to them, or it is about them before someone else.
We must embrace the truth. That means a daily turning, away from error and toward Christ, for as long as we live. It looks like putting away falsehood, as Ephesians 4:25 says, “Therefore, having put away falsehood, let each one of you speak the truth with his neighbor, for we are members one of another.” This is real life stuff. When a conversation turns to gossip, you not only shouldn’t join in, you should say, ‘I don't think we should be talking about him or her like this.’ Sentences like that rarely happen, but they need to, and when they do, God is honored and our neighbor is protected.
We must love the truth, and love the neighbor in the truth. Ephesians 4:15 says we’re to “speak the truth in love.” Love and truth go together. The catechism says to rejoice in our neighbor’s good name, to cover their infirmities, and to defend their innocence. This doesn't mean pretending sin isn’t sin. It means you refuse to broadcast what doesn’t need broadcasting, in person, over text, online, wherever it may be. When you really love someone, you become their protector, and their reputation ought to be safe with you.
This is the ninth commandment's positive call: pursue truth, acknowledge truth, embrace truth, and love truth, until your neighbor's good name is as safe in your hands as your own.
Conclusion:
Now, a terrible way to end this sermon would be to say, ‘Stop lying. Tell the truth. Try harder.’
Why is that terrible? Because it leaves you looking to you. Think about why we lie. We lie because we’re afraid. Somewhere in us is this thought, ‘If they really knew me, they would leave.’ So we edit our story. We polish our image. We hide what’s true to keep the love we’re afraid of losing.
If all you hear today is ‘stop lying’ there’s a good chance you’ll make the opposite error. You’ll begin to build a new image, the image of a truth-teller, where others respect you for being so committed to the truth. What’s the problem with this? It’s still an edited and polished version of you that you’re creating for others, that we’ve made because we want to be accepted by others.
So let me end this in a better way.
In Matthew 26 the chief priests are looking for false testimony against Jesus. Many false witnesses come forward. Liars line up to take the stand against Jesus. And Jesus stands there and says nothing, as Isaiah said He would “like a lamb that is led to the slaughter…He opened not His mouth.” (Isa 53:7).
Though He committed no sin, though no deceit found in His mouth, though He was perfectly truthful, He was condemned by lies. Why? Because he was taking our place.
“The LORD has laid on Him the iniquity of us all” (Isa 53:6). Every false word, every slander, every lie we told to cover ourselves, He carried to the cross and paid for in full. And then all who come to Him in faith, He gives to them…what? His perfect record. His perfect truthfulness counted as our own.
Now hear this, Church. Because of Jesus’ work for us, the courtroom is closed. The Judge has ruled. Your Advocate is at his right hand. The verdict is in. Not guilty. You don’t have to hide, and you don’t have to edit, polish, or build an image. Your name is already secure in Christ.
That is what makes you free to be truthful. When you don’t need a good reputation to survive, you’re glad to be honest. When you’re secure in Christ, you can be at peace, and when you’re at peace you can be glad to guard your neighbor’s name.
Jack Nicholson told Tom Cruise in the movie A Few Good Men “You can’t handle the truth!” Church, you can. You can handle the truth. So, give yourself to the truth, and be a person of the truth. Not to earn love from others, but because you’re already loved in Christ.
This is where freedom is. “…you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free” (John 8:32).
[1] Scott Clark, The Heidelberg Catechism: A Historical, Theological, and Pastoral Commentary (Bellingham, WA: Lexham Press, 2025) 803.
[2] Clark, 800.
[3] Clark, 800.
[4] Clark, 801.
[5] Prov. 31:8 gives us wisdom on the sin of being too silent as well.